Alternative providers of higher and further education may now be able to claim VAT refunds. This follows a recent Court of Appeal ruling. However, the position is still subject to further legal proceedings. So, VAT on education: could providers be entitled to refunds? Below, we explain what the decision means and what happens next.
What the Court of Appeal decided
HMRC recently published a brief explaining the implications of the Court of Appeal’s decision. In its ruling, the court found in favour of the college in question. As a result, it overturned earlier tribunal decisions. The court also applied principles from an earlier case concerning fiscal neutrality. In simple terms, fiscal neutrality means similar supplies should get similar VAT treatment.
How the ruling differs from HMRC policy
The decision means some educational supplies may qualify for exemption from standard-rate VAT. This applies even where the provider is not an eligible body. Until now, HMRC has taken a different view. Its longstanding policy treats education from providers that are not eligible bodies as subject to standard-rate VAT. Consequently, the ruling could have a significant impact on alternative providers across the sector.
What happens next?
HMRC has received permission to appeal to the Supreme Court. Therefore, the final outcome is still uncertain. In the meantime, alternative providers can take action. If you are in the same position as the college, you can submit a refund claim. HMRC will then consider these claims while the Supreme Court appeal is pending.
How HMRC will assess claims
HMRC will consider each claim individually. In particular, it will take account of several factors, including:
- unjust enrichment
- partial exemption
- whether businesses have correctly accounted for overdeclared VAT throughout the supply chain.
Additionally, claims must reflect any input tax you have previously recovered. This means you can only claim the net amount. Furthermore, all claims must meet normal statutory requirements and time limits. For this reason, you should act promptly and keep accurate records.
Why professional advice matters
VAT on education: could providers be entitled to refunds? For many alternative providers, the answer may well be yes. However, the rules are complex, and the legal position could still change. Therefore, you should prepare carefully before submitting any claim. Equally, you should consider how the Supreme Court’s decision might affect your position.
Speak to our VAT team
Are you an alternative education provider wondering whether you could reclaim VAT? Our VAT specialists can review your position and help you prepare a claim. Get in touch with Ecovis today to find out more.







