Take care when painting non-compete clauses with a broad brush
Commercial suppliers fight hard to protect their local customer networks. However, a recent High Court judgement has exposed a real danger. Standard “boilerplate” contracts often fail when they try to restrict departing sales staff. Therefore, employers must take care when painting non-compete clauses with a broad brush.
The dispute in focus
A national building supplies merchant triggered the case. Specifically, it sought final injunctions against its former area sales manager. Under his contract, the defendant worked as a peripatetic area sales manager. Moreover, he handled high-value client accounts across the local regions.
The contract set a one-week notice period during probation. Yet it also imposed extensive post-termination restrictions. These included a six-month, geographically defined non-compete covenant. In addition, it contained a twelve-month confidentiality clause.
Access, resignation and the alleged approach
Throughout his employment, the defendant used the merchant’s digital management systems. Notably, these systems recorded customer transaction histories, pipeline projects, and a variable pricing hierarchy.
Some months later, the defendant resigned. Consequently, he assumed a three-month notice obligation. Meanwhile, he prepared to join a direct competitor as an external sales manager. There, he would help launch a new regional branch.
Soon afterwards, his former employer grew concerned. Indeed, regional clients on his sales ledger were being actively engaged. The merchant referenced one professional networking exchange in particular. During it, the defendant allegedly told a buyer to reroute quotes through his new employer. As a result, the merchant issued a formal legal claim. Furthermore, it secured an interim injunction to enforce both the covenant and a temporary confidentiality restriction.
The High Court’s decision
Ultimately, the High Court dismissed the employer’s claims. The Judge declared the non-compete covenant void and unenforceable. In addition, the Court rejected the application for a final confidentiality injunction.
Fatal drafting flaws
The Judge focused firmly on drafting flaws. Above all, the agreement dismantled a contractual “carve-out”. This clause originally let the employee work in non-competing areas. Later, the former employer attempted a belated “blue-pencil” deletion. However, the High Court refused. An employer cannot retroactively rewrite a relaxation clause to limit a former employee’s freedom.
The Quilter point
Next, the Court applied the “Quilter point”. Because the manager could be dismissed at a week’s notice during probation, the ban looked excessive. Therefore, a six-month blanket ban from “day one” proved fundamentally disproportionate.
Screen prices, not trade secrets
Finally, the Court examined the pricing schedules. In truth, the internal software listed merely artificial screen prices. Genuine commodity prices fluctuate rapidly due to global market forces. Consequently, regional builders openly share competitor quotes to drive down costs. Thus, the departing manager held no stable trade secrets to exploit.
Lessons for employers
This judgement offers clear warnings. Employers should therefore review their standard contracts closely. Consider the following points:
- Check internal consistency. Structurally inconsistent restrictions will likely be struck down entirely.
- Avoid geographic bloat. Overly wide covenants leave client databases exposed rather than protected.
- Never redraft retrospectively. Courts reject belated attempts to expand a post-termination boundary.
- Match restrictions to seniority. Use variable, ascending tiers linked to service length and role.
Above all, remember one principle. A non-competition restriction is only as strong as your wider framework. Consequently, you must take care when painting non-compete clauses with a broad brush.
Furthermore, notice periods matter enormously. If you can dismiss an introductory employee at a week’s notice, a six-month lockout looks unreasonable. Indeed, courts may view it as an unlawful restraint of trade. Therefore, corporate counsel should tailor each clause carefully.
Call to action
Do your restrictive covenants stand up to scrutiny? Don’t wait for a costly dispute to find out. Contact our team today for a tailored contract review. Together, we will help you protect your customer networks properly.







